2019 NFL DRAFT REVIEW

Time to look back at this year’s NFL draft and how it all went from my point of view. I allowed myself a couple of days once the event was over to settle down before going back over the picks round-by-round while my mind was still in “draft mode”.

When preparing this review I wanted to try and incorporate as best as I could my pre-draft position rankings (take a look at them here!), each team’s draft class and my own Top 100 results.  I have chosen to follow a similar style to previous reviews – which is to initially list the first 100 picks, with some detail on each of the players selected in the first round and thereafter only something on any other pick that I feel noteworthy.  This way I feel like it will reduce the risk of me simply repeating my thoughts on each player (what sort of player they are, how their new team will play them etc.) from my position rankings.

Below are the first 100 picks of the 2019 NFL draft.

1.  Kyler Murray, QB, Arizona Cardinals – Those who have read any of my pre-draft work will know I was against the idea of the Cardinals taking Murray at #1 (and I still am!).  With all the coverage hinting towards it, the move became inevitable and therefore was not a surprise when Murray’s name was indeed called as the opening pick of the draft.  This immediately put Arizona’s quarterback Josh Rosen into the spotlight as it was clear he would not stay with Murray’s arrival.  Rosen was traded to the Miami Dolphins during round two (a nice deal for the Dolphins).  If the new-look Cardinals offense works with Murray the team will be an exciting watch.
2.  Nick Bosa, DE, San Francisco 49ers – With the Cardinals taking Murray, the 49ers would have been very happy to be able to get Bosa – one of the best players in the draft and fills a need.
3.  Quinnen Williams, DT, New York Jets – Another of the top guys in this year’s draft, and the Jets were not going to ignore him. Williams is the type of player who would improve any defensive line and should make an immediate impact.
4.  Clelin Ferrell, DE, Oakland Raiders – The first surprise of the night. A pleasant one for me as I rate Ferrell very highly yet did not expect him to go this early. The Raiders obviously see it too.
5.  Devin White, LB, Tampa Bay Buccaneers – White was the player I wanted the Raiders to go with at #4. Not only because of his talent but I also thought it would have a knock-on effect of making the rest of the first round a bit more unpredictable. A sensible choice for the Buccaneers, who will place White in the middle of their linebacker group.
6.  Daniel Jones, QB, New York Giants – The most divisive and talked-about pick of the entire draft. Possessing THREE first round picks, the Giants decided to go quarterback straight away. I had thought they would look to address the position.  With Drew Lock and Dwayne Haskins available, and also Josh Rosen seemingly an option via a trade with Arizona, the Giants made Daniel Jones their man.  I think the main problem with the pick is that it was made as early as #6 – Jones would surely have still been around for them later in the first or even the start of the second round.  I can see why they like Jones so much as he was coached by the same guys as Eli Manning, who Jones will get the chance to learn from instead of being thrown into a starting role.  I think it will be a good thing for him to have this time to develop.
7.  Josh Allen, OLB, Jacksonville Jaguars – I suspect the Jaguars couldn’t get this pick in fast enough! Not necessarily a need but the best player available, Allen will line up best at outside linebacker and can also be moved up to play defensive end.
8.  T. J. Hockenson, TE, Detroit Lions – Hockenson will upgrade the Lions offense in both the passing and running game. I really hope this breaks Detroit’s habit of struggling with tight ends they draft in the first round.
9.  Ed Oliver, DT, Buffalo Bills – A great pick. The Bills were never going to resist Oliver, who has all the tools to make an impression from day one with room to improve as well. You know a player has potential when number 9 feels like a bargain.
10.  Devin Bush, LB, Pittsburgh Steelers – At this point the Steelers became the first team of the night to trade up. In true AFC North style they did so at the expense of divisional rivals the Cincinnati Bengals, who they jumped in front of to nab linebacker Devin Bush. He’ll fit the aggressive tone that Pittsburgh likes from it’s defense.
11.  Jonah Williams, OT, Cincinnati Bengals – Linebacker was a real need for the Bengals so missing out on Bush must have affected their draft board.  They still made a really solid pick by choosing Williams.  He will instantly improve their offensive line.
12.  Rashan Gary, DE, Green Bay Packers – There was talk of Gary dropping come the beginning of the draft so I was happy to see him taken here. I like him as a versatile player with the size to move inside the D line if coaches want him to.
13.  Christian Wilkins, DT, Miami Dolphins – As I mentioned earlier when referring to their trade for Josh Rosen, I liked how the Dolphins went about this draft and it all began with taking Christian Wilkins. He’s a class act with good team ethic and should put up some good production for Miami.
14.  Chris Lindstrom, OG, Atlanta Falcons – I have been high on Lindstrom for a long time so I liked seeing him selected by the Falcons in the middle of the first. I suspect Atlanta could have been in for both Gary and Wilkins had either still been available. This is a move designed to help their run game and protect quarterback Matt Ryan.
15.  Dwayne Haskins, QB, Washington Redskins – Haskins to the Redskins travelled around the NFL rumour mill more and more as the event approached. It will be interesting to see how soon he can challenge to be starting for Washington under center.
16.  Brian Burns, DE, Carolina Panthers – A talent like Burns falling to #16 goes to show how much depth there was in this edge rusher class. The Panthers can use him in a variety of ways on the defensive side of the ball.
17.  Dexter Lawrence, DT, New York Giants – The Giants got this pick as part of the trade prior to the draft that sent Odell Beckham to the Cleveland Browns. They used it to bulk up the middle of their defensive line; in Lawrence they get a guy who works well against running plays with room to improve on his technique.
18.  Garrett Bradbury, C, Minnesota Vikings – I predicted Bradbury as a safe pick for the Vikings. Plenty of experience at center and he can also move across to play guard if required.
19.  Jeffery Simmons, DT, Tennessee Titans – Simmons will not play for a season due to his recent knee injury.  The Titans were not put off and made sure he remained a first rounder – an indication of how highly regarded he is as a prospect.
20.  Noah Fant, TE, Denver Broncos – Nice work here by the Broncos as they traded down ten places and still got a real offensive weapon.  Fant’s strong potential as a target in the passing game will help Denver’s new quarterback group.
21.  Darnell Savage Jr, S, Green Bay Packers – This was another pick that I called correctly!  I had the Packers selecting Savage Jr. at #30 and they traded up and still went with him.  It’s a pick I like a lot as he rose throughout the process all the way into round one.
22.  Andre Dillard, OT, Philadelphia Eagles – The Eagles traded up a few places to make a nice addition to the O line. Dillard is a very good pass blocker so Carson Wentz should approve this decision.
23.  Tytus Howard, OT, Houston Texans – The Houston Texans were always going to address their offensive line but this feels like a reach.  At this point it became clear the likes of Jawaan Taylor and Cody Ford were falling badly.  Howard was quite a way down my rankings so seeing him go in the first round was a bit of a shock.
24.  Josh Jacobs, RB, Oakland Raiders – Jacobs to the Raiders must have been the most nailed on pick this year. Whether it was with #24 or #27 almost everyone had them taking the best running back in the draft.
25.  Marquise Brown, WR, Baltimore Ravens – One of the most dynamic players in the whole draft.  I still did not expect Brown to be selected until day two despite his entertainment value.  It will be interesting to see how the Ravens use him as his lack of size remains a concern.
26.  Montez Sweat, DE, Washington Redskins – Washington traded back into the first round to foil the Raiders and grab Sweat.  He will add some tempo to their pass rush and could prove the trade to be good value.
27.  Johnathan Abram, S, Oakland Raiders – Abram is a real banger of a safety and I was not surprised to see he was one of the first taken at the position despite marking him down in my own rankings for sometimes being over-aggressive.  I can imagine head coach Jon Gruden loving his style.
28.  Jerry Tillery, DT, Los Angeles Chargers – Nice selection here for the Chargers. Tillery fills a need and should contribute early on the D line, especially as a pass rusher from the inside.
29.  L.J. Collier, DE, Seattle Seahawks – As has been a habit in recent years, the Seahawks spent the first night making deals to accumulate more picks in the later rounds. When they did make a move for a player it came at #29 with the addition of Collier – a power-based edge rusher. Exactly what they needed.
30.  DeAndre Baker, CB, New York Giants – I was not surprised to see Baker as the first cornerback picked. He has good length and ability to read plays and was my favourite of the Giants three first round selections.
31. Kaleb McGary, OT, Atlanta Falcons – Atlanta traded up for another go at a first rounder and added a second offensive lineman.  That’s investing a lot across that line.  With McGary going here and the Patriots looking elsewhere it confirmed that Taylor and Ford (two OTs thought of as sure first round picks) slid into day two.
32.  N’Keal Harry, WR, New England Patriots – Harry is drafted into an excellent situation here.  He was the top receiver in my rankings and joining the Patriots offense could help him become a top player.
33.  Byron Murphy, CB, Arizona Cardinals – Putting aside my issues with Kyler Murray, the Cardinals appeared to begin each round with a nice pick and assembled a very good final draft class.  They kicked-off round two by taking a real all-rounder in Murphy, a move that started a run on cornerbacks, with plenty taken throughout the second round.
34.  Rock Ya-Sin, CB, Indianapolis Colts
35.  Jawaan Taylor, OT, Jacksonville Jaguars – Taylor’s drop ended here at the start of the second.  I had him as a potential top 10 pick but it was concerns about one of his knees that caused him to fall to #35 for the Jaguars to get a steal.
36.  Deebo Samuel, WR, San Francisco 49ers
37.  Greg Little, OT, Carolina Panthers
38.  Cody Ford, OT, Buffalo Bills – Another great pick for the Bills.  The reason for Ford’s slide out of the first round is not as clear as Taylor’s.  Buffalo won’t mind as their good draft continued here.
39.  Sean Bunting, CB, Tampa Bay Buccaneers
40.  Trayvon Mullen, CB, Oakland Raiders
41.  Dalton Risner, OT, Denver Broncos
42.  Drew Lock, QB, Denver Broncos – The Broncos also put together a good draft class.  They made a couple of nice moves back-to-back by first taking strong offensive line prospect Dalton Risner, then here they selected Drew Lock to be their quarterback of the future.  General manager John Elway does not have a great record with choosing quarterbacks but I hope this works out as Lock is my favourite QB in this year’s draft.
43.  Jahlani Tavai, LB, Detroit Lions – Each time that I have done a Top 100, my first miss always seems to come in the mid-40s.  2019 was no different as Tavai was the first name not on my list.  Linebacker was probably the position I missed on the most.  I thought Tavai had a poor combine and did not see him as a second round player at all.
44.  Elgton Jenkins, C, Green Bay Packers
45.  Joejuan Williams, CB, New England Patriots
46.  Greedy Williams, CB, Cleveland Browns – Cleveland’s opening pick was a nice move to get Greedy Williams.  There is still room for him to improve so #46 feels about right value-wise.  On paper, at least, the Browns are building a really good team.
47.  Marquise Blair, S, Seattle Seahawks – The second guy not in my Top 100.  You can see why the Seahawks like Blair; a tough, hard-hitting safety who fits how they like to play defense.
48.  Erik McCoy, C, New Orleans Saints
49.  Ben Banogu, OLB, Indianapolis Colts
50.  Irv Smith Jr, TE, Minnesota Vikings
51.  A. J. Brown, WR, Tennessee Titans – Wide receiver was a real need for the Titans so it was a great idea to go with Brown at #51.  They will be able to line him up in a variety of ways and still count on him to make a play.
52.  Drew Sample, TE, Cincinnati Bengals – Tight end appears to be another position I missed on a bit.  Despite that I still feel that Sample going here is very high.
53.  Miles Sanders, RB, Philadelphia Eagles
54.  Lonnie Johnson Jr, CB, Houston Texans
55.  Max Scharping, OT, Houston Texans
56.  Mecole Hardman, WR, Kansas City Chiefs – Hardman is one of my favourite players in this draft.  I felt like I was higher than most on him pre-draft but the league obviously agreed on his value as he went in round two to the Chiefs, who really like using speedy receivers.
57.  J.J. Arcega-Whiteside, WR, Philadelphia Eagles
58.  Trysten Hill, DT, Dallas Cowboys – One of my top sleepers, I was still surprised to see Hill picked as high as round two.  I look forward to seeing how the Cowboys play him on their D line.
59.  Parris Campbell, WR, Indianapolis Colts
60.  Nasir Adderley, S, Los Angeles Chargers
61.  Taylor Rapp, S, Los Angeles Rams
62.  Andy Isabella, WR, Arizona Cardinals
63.  Juan Thornhill, S, Kansas City Chiefs
64.  D.K. Metcalf, WR, Seattle Seahawks – As the second round drew to a close the Seahawks traded UP (!) and took D.K. Metcalf.  He was the most discussed WR in the class mainly due to his physique and excellent combine workout.  I felt as though round 2-3 was about right for his value.  His skill-set will suit the Seahawks who have the quarterback in Russell Wilson to send him deep and get him the ball.
65.  Zach Allen, DE, Arizona Cardinals
66.  Diontae Johnson, WR, Pittsburgh Steelers
67.  Jalen Hurd, WR, San Francisco 49ers
68.  Jachai Polite, DE, New York Jets
69.  Josh Oliver, TE, Jacksonville Jaguars
70.  Darrell Henderson, RB, Los Angeles Rams – I thought the Rams had a very good draft.  My favourite of their selections was Henderson.  I really like him and had heard medical rumours so good to see he wasn’t affected by that.
71.  Dre’Mont Jones, DT, Denver Broncos
72.  Germaine Pratt, LB, Cincinnati Bengals
73.  David Montgomery, RB, Chicago Bears
74.  Devin Singletary, RB, Buffalo Bills
75.  Jace Sternberger, TE, Green Bay Packers
76.  Terry McLaurin, WR, Washington Redskins
77.  Chase Winovich, DE, New England Patriots
78.  Michael Deiter, OG, Miami Dolphins
79.  David Long, CB, Los Angeles Rams
80.  Sione Takitaki, LB, Cleveland Browns
81.  Will Harris, S, Detroit Lions
82.  Nate Davis, OG, Tennessee Titans
83.  Justin Layne, CB, Pittsburgh Steelers
84.  Khalen Saunders, DT, Kansas City Chiefs
85.  Jaylon Ferguson, DE, Baltimore Ravens
86.  Kahale Warring, TE, Houston Texans
87.  Damien Harris, RB, New England Patriots
88.  Cody Barton, LB, Seattle Seahawks
89.  Bobby Okereke, LB, Indianapolis Colts
90.  Connor McGovern, OG, Dallas Cowboys
91.  Trey Pipkins, OT, Los Angeles Chargers
92.  Chuma Edoga, OT, New York Jets
93.  Miles Boykin, WR, Baltimore Ravens
94.  Jamel Dean, CB, Tampa Bay Buccaneers
95.  Oshane Ximines, DE, New York Giants
96.  Dawson Knox, TE, Buffalo Bills
97.  Bobby Evans, OT, Los Angeles Rams
98.  Quincy Williams, LB, Jacksonville Jaguars – I really liked this selection as it confused everyone!  Some of us had not done any research on Quincy Williams yet here he was being taken in round three.  It turns out he is the older brother of #3 overall pick Quinnen Williams so the Jaguars have gambled on him as the sibling of one of the best players in the draft.
99.  Mike Edwards, S, Tampa Bay Buccaneers
100.  Will Grier, QB, Carolina Panthers – #100 was Will Grier.  I liked the pick as I’m a fan of his game and also he sneaked in while being on my Top 100 list!

At this point it was time to check my Top 100.  I wanted to beat my previous best of 80 from 2016.  And I did… 82!  I also bettered some well-known names – Mel Kiper of ESPN (81), the Draft Network (80) and CBS (75) among others.  After a couple of years in the mid-70s, all of the extra time invested this year obviously made a difference.  It certainly felt good to score higher than a few experts!

I like to look at the players who were in my Top 100 but did not have their names called there in the draft.  They are below.

101.  Yodny Cajuste, OT, New England Patriots
103.  Hakeem Butler, WR, Arizona Cardinals – It’s so frustrating to see how close to the 100 some of these players were!  Butler is a real boom or bust kind of receiver who I rated highly but was not amazed that teams didn’t.  Still expected him to go by round three though.
105. Chauncey Gardner-Johnson, S, New Orleans Saints – Gardner-Johnson was one of the biggest drops of the draft.  He was my top safety and I thought he had a chance to go in the first round!  It turns out there were character issues that pushed him down – must have been bad to push him this far.
107.  Anthony Nelson, DE, Tampa Bay Buccaneers
108.  Julian Love, CB, New York Giants
114.  Dru Samia, OG, Minnesota Vikings
115.  Christian Miller, OLB, Carolina Panthers
116.  Amani Hooker, S, Tennessee Titans
130.  Drue Tranquill, LB, Los Angeles Chargers
139.  Deionte Thompson, S, Arizona Cardinals
146.  Amani Oruwariye, CB, Detroit Lions – Cornerbacks have been the position I have lost on in past Top 100’s.  I was much better this year but Oruwariye falling to #146 seemed liked a lot, especially as I thought he would go in round two.
153.  Ross Pierschbacher, C, Washington Redskins – I always make the odd decision in the Top 100 with my heart rather than my head.  Pierschbacher has been my top center for a while; I knew the league did not see him in the same light so was not surprised that he did not make it.
155.  Mack Wilson, LB, Cleveland Browns
157. Blake Cashman, LB, New York Jets – Two more picks here showing how I missed on the linebackers.  With Cashman’s dodgy medical record, the fifth round when the Jets took him is probably right.
161.  Charles Omenihu, DE, Houston Texans
168.  D’Andre Walker, OLB, Tennessee Titans
206.  Kelvin Harmon, WR, Washington Redskins – I have not been sure about Harmon throughout the whole draft process but went along with the buzz of his highlights over his slow combine effort.  Should have stuck with my instincts!  Although dropping to #206 seems a bit much so there must be more to it than just concerns about his lack of speed.
Undrafted.  DaMarkus Lodge, WR, Tampa Bay Buccaneers – Lodge is another player I know I’m higher on than most.  However, I still expected him to be drafted!  Since the draft he has signed a contract with the Tampa Bay Buccaneers.

As I stated in my power rankings post, I have never gone deeper than this year when researching an NFL draft.  For this reason the hundreds of names from the 2019 class will always be of interest to me and I look forward to seeing how they all progress.

Each year I enjoy the whole process of the combine, scouting film and finding where all the good information is coming from.  I want to give a mention to Paul at NFL Draft Line – a fellow British fan of the draft who does such good work he is always in contention for the Huddle Report’s Top 100 competition.  Perhaps I will be able to officially enter the competition myself one day!

It’s finally time to get out of “draft mode” as the NFL moves into the off-season.

I have a facebook page to accompany this blog.  On the page there is regular news and views on all things NFL.  If you are interested and also want to keep up with any future blog posts give it a visit (and a “like”!) here – http://www.facebook.com/Liam66NFL